The Guardian vs. the Goon: PA’s Most Important Governor’s Race

The choice for Pennsylvania Governor could not be more clear in November.

On the one hand, we have Josh Shapiro – an Attorney General who fought for Commonwealth citizens’ rights for six years.

On the other, we have Doug Mastriano, a former US Army Colonel and 3-year state representative who supported a literal coup against the United States government.

In any sane world, that would be all you’d need to know.

Shapiro, the state’s chief law enforcement officer, vs. Mastriano, a traitor who actively worked to overturn the votes of the very citizens who elected him to office.

This should not be an election – it should be a rout.

However, Commonwealth voters will need to come to the polls and make it clear that they reject Mastriano’s fascism and that they instead support their own right to determine who governs in Pennsylvania and beyond.

That sounds extreme. I wish it weren’t also true.

Following the last Presidential election when it became clear Donald Trump had lost the vote, Republican Mastriano helped organize large rallies pushing false claims of election fraud. He chartered buses to take protesters to the Capitol on January 6. He personally crossed police barricades at the Capitol during the riot, and attempted to submit “alternate” (i.e. fake) pro-Trump electors to the official count. And he even coordinated all this with Trump when he was invited to the White House to discuss the “stop the steal” strategy.

If Mastriano somehow wins the governors race, he will be in a position to basically call off Democratic rule in the state. As governor, he would choose the secretary of state — the official in charge of administering the 2024 presidential election. This would effectively allow him to pick the winner, himself.

This is not just conjecture. Mastriano has gone on record that as governor he would decertify voting machines in some precincts – making it hard to count votes there. He has even alluded to the independent state legislature doctrine, which holds that state legislatures can name whoever they want as the recipient of a state’s electoral votes, regardless of who voters select.

This is not conservatism. It is not protecting American values or law and order. It is the opposite.

By contrast, Shapiro, the Democrat in the race, is a model of exactly those qualities usually associated with sobriety and efficiency.

As Attorney General, he fought federal government overreach including Trump’s travel ban. He filed a lawsuit to stop religious organizations denying health coverage including contraceptives to employees. He joined a lawsuit against for profit colleges resulting in a $168 million settlement. He reached an agreement with federal officials to prevent the distribution of blueprints for 3D printed firearms. He launched an investigation of allegations of sexual abuse by members of the Catholic Church including a Grand Jury report alleging the sexual abuse of more than a thousand children at the hands of more than 300 priests.

In short, he worked hard to protect the people of this Commonwealth.

And the difference is stark on so many other issues when compared head-to-head.

Shapiro supports increasing public school funding. Mastriano wants to cut it in half.

Shapiro wants to increase security and gun regulations to prevent school shootings. Mastriano wants to give teachers guns and let them do the shooting.

Shapiro has fought to protect women’s reproductive rights against the state. Mastriano supports the state telling people what to do with their own bodies.

And on top of all that – Mastriano has ties to White Supremacists!

Until recently, his campaign paid consulting fees to Gab, a white nationalist social media site owned by anti-Semite Andrew Torba. Gab was the site that helped inspire the Pittsburgh Tree of Life Synagogue mass murder in 2018. Torba and others on the site that Mastriano was explicitly looking to for support commonly champion Great Replacement theory and support Vladimir Putin.

No skeletons of this type have been found in Shapiro’s closet.

The worst anyone has found so far is a $100,000 donation from Students First PA, a charter school advocacy group, which he took money from when he was running for Attorney General in 2016. However, Shapiro made no effort to hide the donation and his voting record when he was a state representative was not pro-charter. In 2011, for example, he voted against a measure to provide tuition vouchers of charter schools, and he has been a vocal critic of the industry for years. Moreover, neither Students First PA nor any other pro-education privatization organization that I can find has made any significant donations to him this election cycle so far.

The way I see it, this is a simple – if terrifying – election.

Shapiro is not perfect, but if elected, he would function similarly to current Governor Tom Wolf. He would be a guardian against the overreach and bad decisions of the gerrymandered Republican legislature.

One can hope voters throughout the Commonwealth would take back their individual voting districts from the extremists, but given the still uncompetitive lines of these districts, this seems unlikely.

So we need a Wolf, we need a Shapiro, standing on the battlements stopping the goons like Mastriano from taking advantage of the majority of us.

Shapiro would certainly do that. He might even go farther and fight to find ways to get real change through the legislature. But even if he can’t do that, voting for him is essential.

Mastriano may simply be the worst candidate for governor in the Commonwealth’s history – and that’s saying something!

We need Shapiro. We need Austin Davis as Lt. Governor. And we need John Fetterman as Senator.

That would make a huge difference both nationally and throughout the state.

It would set us up with a firm foundation and at least keep people safe from the worst.

I know it is depressing to be put in this situation constantly. Every election cycle seems to be the most important because the country is falling apart. Maybe we can find a way to turn things back and reach some level of sanity. But we can’t do anything unless we elect Shapiro, Davis and Fetterman.

We need the guardians against the goons.

Like this post?  You might want to consider becoming a Patreon subscriber. This helps me continue to keep the blog going and get on with this difficult and challenging work.

Plus you get subscriber only extras!



I’ve also written a book, “Gadfly on the Wall: A Public School Teacher Speaks Out on Racism and Reform,” now available from Garn Press. Ten percent of the proceeds go to the Badass Teachers Association. Check it out!


16 thoughts on “The Guardian vs. the Goon: PA’s Most Important Governor’s Race

  1. Liberal PACs spent big bucks in the last primary to back Mastriano’s bid for the nomination; the logic being that he would be the easiest GOP candidate to defeat.

    That logic may play out, but if it doesn’t…

    The scary part is that if it wasn’t for the SCOTUS overturning Roe and activating pretty much all non-Conversative women, the polling gap would likely not be as wide as it is now.

    Let’s see if Shapiro and Fetterman, a very symbiotic pair in the run-up to November, can land this plane safely.


    • Thanks for commenting, Dan. I read about this, too, and find it absolutely infuriating! This is exactly what the Hillary Clinton campaign did about Donald Trump in the primary. They boosted him over his more (relatively) moderate opponents and then lost the general election. It’s a losing strategy and I wish the political class wouldn’t take such chances to popularize the most extreme positions of the GOP just because they think they can ultimately beat them in the general election.


      • That’s an interesting point, and as a tactic, it should work and would have worked in 2016, as long as well-intentioned folks stay informed and don’t throw their vote away on a third-party candidate.


      • Liberal PAC’s in MD boosted QAnon/MAGA Dan Cox. Our choices are now a liar/grifter Wes Moore or crazy Dan Cox. We are screwed and I fear that people will stay home instead of voting. I hope Hogan takes a run for President…….I’m a Dem, but I think Hogan did an exceptional job playing to the middle and compromising on hard issues.


  2. Traitor Trump and his MAGA Fascist Party have infiltered the Republican Party and Traitor’s candidates are running in the primaries in many states against traditional Republicans and some of Traitors MAGA fascists are winning some of those primaries to run against Democrats in November 2022.

    Traitor Donald Trump (Traitor is his first name now) has attempted at least 8 plots to overthrow the election so far, and most involved unlawful or criminal acts. As the 7th plot was thwarted, his treasonous gang turned to #8, what we saw on Jan. 6, 2021.

    An MSNBC Beat Special Report on the wider conspiracy — two excerpts:

    Part 1:

    Part 2:

    But Traitor and his domestic-terrorist fascists are not finished. The midterm elections near the end of this year will be #9, another attempt as Traitor tries to get as many of his totally, loyal-only to him MAGA fascists to win state and federal positions. Once Traitor controls a state through his elected MAGA fascists, he’ll change each of those state’s laws giving him more power to overturn elections, the will of the people through the popular vote. Well, in about 19 of the RED states, the MAGA fascists are already doing that.

    Traditional Republicans are fighting back but the majority of registered Republican voters are MAGA fascists loyal only to Traitor Donald Trump, also known as the Boss by his shit-stained tongue, ass-licking enablers.

    As long as Traitor Donald Trump avoids prison and being sued into poverty, and his dangerously dumber-than-dumb loyalists keep donating their money to him, he’ll never stop trying to overthrow our government even if he reaches 100.


    • I can only agree with your assertion, Lloyd. I do not understand why AG Garland and the DOJ do not understand that the behavior we accept is the behavior that will become the norm.

      If Donald Trump does not end his days in a jail cell, his presidency will become a model for the future of this country.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.