Donald Trump lies.
If you haven’t learned that yet, America, you’ve got four more cringe-inducing years to do so.
Even in his inaugural address, he couldn’t help but let loose a whooper about US public schools.
“Americans want great schools for their children, safe neighborhoods for their families and good jobs for themselves,” he said. “But for too many of our citizens, a different reality exists. … An education system flush with cash but which leaves our young and beautiful students deprived of all knowledge.”
To which nearly every poor, nonwhite public school parent, student and teacher in the country replied, “What’s that heck did he just say now!?”
Los Angeles Unified School district routinely has broken desks and chairs, missing ceiling tiles, damaged flooring, broken sprinklers, damaged lunch tables and broken toilet paper dispensers.
They’re flush with cash!?
New York City public schools removed more than 160 toxic light fixtures containing polychlorinated biphenyls, a cancer causing agent that also hinders cognitive and neurological development. Yet many schools are still waiting on a fix, especially those serving minority students.
They’re flush with cash!?
At Charles L. Spain school in Detroit, the air vents are so warped and moldy, turning on the heat brings a rancid stench. Water drips from a leaky roof into the gym, warping the floor tiles. Cockroaches literally scurry around some children’s classrooms until they are squashed by student volunteers.
They’re flush with freakin cash!?
Are you serious, Donald Trump!?
And this same picture is repeated at thousands of public schools across the nation especially in impoverished neighborhoods. Especially in communities serving a disproportionate number of black, Latino or other minority students.
In predominantly white, upper class neighborhoods, the schools often ARE “flush with cash.” Olympic size swimming pools, pristine bathrooms – heck – air conditioning! But in another America across the tracks, schools are defunded, ignored and left to rot.
A full 35 states provide less overall state funding for education today than they did in 2008, according to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, which focuses on reducing poverty and inequality. Most states still haven’t recovered from George W. Bush’s Great Recession and the subsequent state and local budget cuts it caused. In fact, over the same period, per pupil funding fell in 27 states and still hasn’t recovered.
And the federal government has done little to help alleviate the situation. Since 2011, spending on major K-12 programs – including Title I grants for underprivileged students and special education – has been basically flat.
The problem is further exacerbated by the incredibly backward way we allocate funding at the local level which bears the majority of the cost of education.
While most advanced countries divide their school dollars evenly between students, the United States does not. Some students get more, some get less. It all depends on local wealth.
The average per pupil expenditure for U.S. secondary students is $12,731. But that figure is deceiving. It is an average. Some kids get much more. Many get much less. It all depends on where you live. If your home is in a rich neighborhood, more money is spent on your education than if you live in a poor neighborhood.
The U.S. is one of the only countries in the world – if not probably the ONLY country – that funds schools based largely on local taxes. Other developed nations either equalize funding or provide extra money for kids in need. In the Netherlands, for example, national funding is provided to all schools based on the number of pupils enrolled. But for every guilder allocated to a middle-class Dutch child, 1.25 guilders are allocated for a lower-class child and 1.9 guilders for a minority child – exactly the opposite of the situation in the U.S.
So, no. Our schools are not “flush with cash.” Just the opposite in many cases.
But what about Trump’s other claim – the much touted narrative of failing schools?
Trump says our schools “leave… our young and beautiful students deprived of all knowledge.”
Not true.
Graduation rates are at an all-time high of 83.2 percent. Moreover, for the first time minority students are catching up with their white counterparts.
It’s only international comparisons of standardized test scores that support this popular myth of academic failure. And, frankly, even that is based on a warped and unfair reading of those results.
It depends on how you interpret the data.
Raw data shows US children far from the top of the scale. It puts us somewhere in the middle – where we’ve always been for all the decades since they’ve been making these comparisons. Our schools have not gotten worse. They have stayed the same.
However, this ignores a critical factor – poverty. We’ve known for decades that standardized tests are poor measures of academic success. Bubble tests can assess simple things but nothing complex. After all, they’re scored based on answers to multiple choice questions. In fact, the only thing they seem to measure with any degree of accuracy is the parental income of the test-taker. Kids from rich families score well, and poor kids score badly.
Virtually all of the top scoring countries taking these exams have much less child poverty than the U.S. If they had the same percentage of poor students that we do, their scores would be lower than ours. Likewise, if we had the same percentage of poor students that they do, our scores would go through the roof! We would have the best scores in the world!
Moreover, the U.S. education system does something that many international systems do not. We educate everyone! Foreign systems often weed children out by high school. They don’t let every child get 13 years of grade school (counting kindergarten). They only school their highest achievers.
So when we compare ourselves to these countries, we’re comparing ALL of our students to only SOME of theirs – their best academic pupils, to be exact. Yet we still hold our own given these handicaps!
This suggests that the majority of problems with our public schools aren’t bad teachers, or a lack of charter schools and school choice. It’s money, pure and simple.
We invest the majority of our education funding in rich white kids. The poor and minorities are left to fend for themselves.
This won’t be solved by Trump’s pick for Education Secretary, Betsy DeVos and her school choice schemes. In fact, that’s exactly what’s weakened public schools across the country by leaching away what meager funding these districts have left. Nor will it be solved by a demagogue telling fairy tales to Washington’s credulous and ignorant.
We need to make a real investment in our public schools. We need to make a commitment to funding poor black kids as fairly as we do rich white kids.
Otherwise, the only thing flushed will be children’s future.
[…] Not in a country that has made education such a low priority for decades. […]
LikeLike
[…] about time! Schools in impoverished neighborhoods are falling apart. We need to bring them up to the same level as those in the upper middle class and wealthy […]
LikeLike
[…] they can be ignored and then blamed for their own underprivileged status. They are the result of national and state policies allowed to play the parasite on their budgets – high stakes testing, Common Core and – yes – charter […]
LikeLike
[…] The Department did increase funding to public schools, but it didn’t end up dramatically increasing opportunities for the underprivileged. […]
LikeLike
[…] course schools need more than just additional funding. But let’s not minimize funding equity. Students of color will never get an equitable education until we pay for the resources they need […]
LikeLike
[…] truth to power about high stakes standardized tests, unaccountable charter and voucher schools, inequitable funding and the boondoggle of Common Core […]
LikeLike
[…] general, the schools with greater needs than funding are where students struggle. The schools where everyone has more than they need is where they […]
LikeLike
[…] a lack of adequate funding is cited as the most common problem facing public schools – a finding that’s held true since […]
LikeLike
[…] general, the schools with greater needs than funding are where students struggle. The schools where everyone has more than they need is where they excel. But they try to sweep […]
LikeLike
[…] schools with less funding mean fewer teachers. That means larger class sizes. That means it’s more difficult to learn – […]
LikeLike
[…] The bottom line is that many people are concerned about inadequate funding for children’s programs. […]
LikeLike
[…] Look at your neighborhood. Wonder why our schools, roads, bridges and other public services are crumbling into disrepair? […]
LikeLike
[…] allocates funding based largely on parental income? […]
LikeLike
[…] They’ve chased every new technological fad without regard to how it affects students or their privacy. They’ve let our schools become increasingly more segregated and made deals with private prison companies and unscrupulous security and business interests that made our schools a gateway to incarceration as much as they are to college or careers. They’ve actively engaged or silently stood by as classroom teachers lost autonomy, rights and professionalism. And finally, though many of them talk a good game, they haven’t done nearly enough to ensure that every student gets the same opportunities, resources and…. […]
LikeLike
[…] It’s trickle down economics – Pennsylvania style. […]
LikeLike
[…] However, in most cases kids don’t struggle because they’re just lazy. They don’t need an incentive. They need help. They need resources. […]
LikeLike
[…] It’s trickle down economics – Pennsylvania style. […]
LikeLike
[…] We need equitable and sustainable funding formulas that aren’t tied to testing or that don’t open the door for […]
LikeLike
[…] of this has real world consequences in the classroom. It means fewer teachers and larger class sizes. It means narrowed curriculum and fewer […]
LikeLike
[…] to help alleviate these costs to local school districts. Neighborhood schools can only try to compensate by cutting services for students where it can and raising property taxes where it can’t make ends […]
LikeLike
[…] America’s schools, just like her roads and bridges, are falling into disrepair. A 2014 study found that at least 53 percent of the nation’s schools need immediate repair. At least 2.3 million students, mostly in rural communities, attend schools without high-speed internet access. Heating and cooling systems don’t work. Some schools have leaks in their roofs. This is just not acceptable. […]
LikeLike
[…] If children of all races went to the same schools with each other, it would be harder to treat them unequally. […]
LikeLike
[…] These are costs too expensive to pay. […]
LikeLike
[…] they are well fed, live in safe homes, have their emotional needs met. Nor have they any say whether they go to a well-resourced school with a wide curriculum, extracurricular activities, school nurses, tutors, mentors, psychologists […]
LikeLike
[…] Ever wonder why our roads and public school buildings are crumbling? […]
LikeLike
[…] Schools overflowing with resources serving rich white kids get a sticker. Schools starving for resources serving poor brown kids get a kick. […]
LikeLike
[…] After years of budget cuts and downsizing, hackers see local governments like wolves see the oldest and weakest animals in the herd – easy pickings. […]
LikeLike
[…] fact that we refuse to invest in our schools only increases the workload of the teachers who are still there. They look around and see students […]
LikeLike
[…] WHAT I LIKE: Everything! Our public schools are crumbling under decades of neglect and targeted disinvestment – especially those serving the poor and […]
LikeLike
[…] So the NAEP shows us what any study of parental income would show. America has a lot of poor kids and underfunded schools. […]
LikeLike
[…] Some complain that this is impossible – that there just isn’t enough money to get this done. […]
LikeLike
[…] want equity for our public schools so all our students can […]
LikeLike
[…] kids need smaller class sizes, more tutoring, librarians, counselors, wider curriculum, etc. The money being spent on them is not wasted. In fact, in a perfect world it would be […]
LikeLike
[…] things like lack of resources and inequality. If kids are failing their classes, it’s too obvious when schools are trying to help but stymied by a lack of resources and countless social issues. Shining a light on that will only lead to solving these very real […]
LikeLike
[…] Schools overflowing with resources serving rich white kids get a sticker. Schools starving for resources serving poor brown kids get a kick. […]
LikeLike
[…] the majority of funding comes from local tax revenues – rich communities give their kids more than enough and poor ones struggle to give them […]
LikeLike
[…] positive charter school that only does the best for its students still needs money to operate. And most districts barely have enough funding for one education system – certainly not two parallel […]
LikeLike
[…] might have just walked into an inner city school to check it out. She would have seen that many schools are literally falling apart. […]
LikeLike
[…] A real investigative journalist might have just walked into an inner city school to check it out. She would have seen that many schools are literally falling apart. […]
LikeLike
[…] GOP is terrified they might actually have to protect voting rights or provide equitable school funding for black kids up to par with white kids, so they have to keep creating scary monsters to frighten the populace into believing their bogus […]
LikeLike
[…] see our students struggle with large class sizes, crumbling infrastructure and facilities, and an overabundance of standardized […]
LikeLike
[…] In an age when school budget cuts are the norm, spending on academics is shrinking just as spending on sports is increasing. Athletics is increasing by up to 40% every year. Meanwhile, teachers are furloughed and academic programs cut as school budgets haven’t even returned to the level they were before the Great Recession. […]
LikeLike
[…] are extremely selective about who gets 12 years of schooling. I don’t love having to explain why complaints about per pupil spending in the US are misleading since they’re talking about averages and we don’t spend the money equally – some kids get […]
LikeLike
[…] wish every student got all the resources necessary to meet his or her needs. No! I wish they got MORE than enough. […]
LikeLike
[…] Walk into any wealthy school in the Commonwealth and look around. You’ll see the equivalent of the Taj Mahal. Now walk into any poor district and look around. You’ll see the equivalent of a slum. […]
LikeLike
[…] Per pupil spending has a positive impact on academic outcomes. And in general the more per pupil spending, the better. […]
LikeLike
[…] we could improve. Even before the pandemic, we were incredibly segregated by race and class. Our funding formulas were often regressive and inadequate. Schools serving mostly poor students didn’t have nearly the resources of those serving rich […]
LikeLike
[…] universal healthcare. No universal daycare. No neonatal care. No robust education funding. And no protection against gun […]
LikeLike
[…] universal healthcare. No universal daycare. No neonatal care. No robust education funding. And no protection against gun […]
LikeLike
[…] universal healthcare. No universal daycare. No neonatal care. No robust education funding. And no protection against gun […]
LikeLike