Being Jewish is not something I advertise.
Some of my earliest memories are trying to explain to school friends that no, I didn’t kill Jesus – and, yes, I do eat matzo but it isn’t made with baby’s blood – and would they like to come over to my house and play Legos?
I’ve been called “yid,” “kike,” “heeb,” even just plain “Jew” with the lips curled and the word hurled at me like a knife.
Heck. When I was a kid even the bus driver called me “moneybags,” though my family was far from rich.
So it makes sense to me that Bernie Sanders isn’t running for President as a Jew first.
He’s running on his policies and experience.
But it still hurts when pundits complain that there are now just two white men vying for the democratic nomination.
Sanders IS Jewish. You know that, right? If he were elected, it would not be business as usual. It would be unprecedented.
Yet that fact is almost always glossed over because it doesn’t fit the media narrative they’re selling.
Sanders is the “crazy socialist,” not the “historic Jew.”
This constant erasure is a slap in the face.
And I mean MY face, not just Sander’s.
I doubt it feels too good to him, either, but it feels personal to me, as well.
My family and I live just outside of Pittsburgh, about a half hour away from the Tree of Life Synagogue in Squirrel Hill where just two years ago 17 people were gunned down in perhaps the worst act of violence against Jews in our nation’s history.
I teach “The Diary of Anne Frank” to middle school children less than 15 minutes away.
I have relatives who belong to that congregation, though I didn’t know any of the 11 people who died.
Let me ask – were they white?
I’ll bet they thought they were, but all it took was an anti-Semite with a gun to challenge that.
Like Bernie, I lost my extended family in the Holocaust – great grandparents, great uncles and aunts, cousins, who I will never meet. I grew up with only the closest of familial relations.
Before I was old enough to get in to see a PG-13 movie, I knew about mass graves, ghettos, cattle cars and crematoriums.
Generation upon generation of European Jewry never expected to be singled out for extermination. They probably thought of themselves as regular, everyday people, too – an US not a THEM.
Bernie would meet that same standard. Like all of us, he knows we’re white only until someone decides we’re not.
So when talking heads decide to erase the fact of Bernie’s ancestry, they aren’t just playing politics. They’re engaged in naked prejudice.
Let me be clear. I don’t bring this up out of some sense of political tokenism. Bernie shouldn’t be recognized just for appearances sake. He needs to be seen for who and what he is.
This isn’t about identity politics. It’s about basic truth.
When some folks complain about the way Bernie speaks or that he yells too much, they’re really showing a xenophobic bigotry.
Bernie is a Jewish man who grew up in New York.That is how people from there talk.
I’ve known scores of people who speak like that – often at the dinner table during family gatherings. Just because it isn’t a part of your personal experience doesn’t make it acceptable to dismiss.
If you belittled someone for speaking with a Spanish accent, it would be called out for what it is – prejudice.
But by ignoring Bernie’s Judaism, you allow all kinds of discriminatory preconceptions to pass as little more than valid criticisms.
Don’t get me wrong.
I don’t think Bernie’s Judaism is the most important thing about him or his campaign.
I wouldn’t support just any Jew who was running. For example, I wouldn’t back Joe Lieberman or Jared Kushner if they were seeking elected office.
But it DOES mean something that Bernie is in the hunt for the Democratic nomination and is Jewish.
For me, he typifies what is best about us.
He embodies the spirit of doing good for others and trying to make the world a better place. He seeks justice in economic, social, racial, gender and political relationships. He tells truth even when it’s uncomfortable to hear. And that includes the truth about the Israeli government’s reprehensible treatment of the Palestinian people.
In his 30 years in Congress he passed mountains of bipartisan legislation as the amendment king. He refused to support the Iraq War or cuts to social security. He supports unions, workers, public schools and universal healthcare.
Being Jewish does not take precedence to those things. But I hope supporting those things will help redefine what people think of when they think of Judaism.
Like this post? You might want to consider becoming a Patreon subscriber. This helps me continue to keep the blog going and get on with this difficult and challenging work.
Plus you get subscriber only extras!
Just CLICK HERE.
I’ve also written a book, “Gadfly on the Wall: A Public School Teacher Speaks Out on Racism and Reform,” now available from Garn Press. Ten percent of the proceeds go to the Badass Teachers Association. Check it out!
4 thoughts on “Bernie Sanders Would Be the First Jewish President – What That Means to Me”
I have followed Bernie for the past 6 years. I love him! Can’t get him past most Dems I know they want middle of the road Dem to lead. I’m 68 years old, not some millennial. Love the man. My friends do not agree, unfortunately. I’m pretty much alone in my age group. I grew up in a suburb of NYC and worked with many Jewish people so I’m used to the loud talking but his honesty and purity is unprecedented in a political candidate, he speaks to my old hippie soul and I support him fully!
I’m 67 and I love Bernie, too. I grew up in the Midwest, but lived for years in a heavily Jewish neighborhood in Chicago’s Region. Then studied German , two years studying in Germany, and grad school in literary studies at Brandeis. My son-in-law is Jewish and grew up in Boston, but he can’t stand Bernie. So much for demographics? One thing I have always appreciated about my Jewish friends is their readiness to help in their community and their activism. I have always known Bernie is Jewish, of course, but never thought of it in the terms it is discussed here. I guess I accepted it as being Bernie, but the idea that it is not just Bernie individually, but culturally and socially makes sense. I have been pleasantly surprised that I have not heard explicit criticism of Bernie being Jewish, but then it can‘t really come from the right because of Trumps own claims to be pro-Jewish and pro-Isreal. Is the anti-„socialism“ stance really just a disguised form of anti-Semitism?
Thanks for commenting, Nancy. I think you’re right to a degree about “socialism” being a dog whistle for antisemitism. Marx, after all, was Jewish, and any fault of his political theories have historically been blamed on Jews as if his criticism of capitalism was the result of a conference of rabbis. Bernie has admitted that his career of activism is inspired by his Jewish upbringing. I would love for some of these values to be more recognized and well known. I think even many Jews would do well to re-evaluate how well we are living up to our own beliefs and treating others with love and respect. For me, Bernie typifies the best about us.
Thanks for commenting, Carla. I have a lot of friends who love Bernie, but it’s frustrating that some prefer Biden or have no preference. It especially bothers me when Jewish people don’t see themselves in Bernie. So much about him reflects my own life. I take the media erasure of his ancestry very personally.